Unnatural Selections will be an irregular feature where I read and review books outside of my comfort zone. I'm always open to trying new genres and expanding my reading palate but I tend to stick to what I know I enjoy. However, it's always nice to step out of your comfort zone every once in awhile!
The Exile fits this bill because it is a graphic novel. However, it
is related to
Outlander, so in that respect it's not completely outside of my comfort zone. I'm willing to give anything a try if it involves Jamie Fraser!
The Exile gives readers an alternative point of view to
Outlander, which is told from Claire's perspective.
The Exile covers only the first third of the
Outlander novel, ending with Claire's
big decision to either stay with Jamie or try to return through the stones to her old life.
I have to say that reading a graphic novel is definitely a different reading experience. I struggled for the first half of the book. I had to "re-read" sections but about halfway through the book I was able to get into the groove of reading a graphic novel.
At first I was apprehensive about the renderings of Jamie, Claire, and other characters. As readers we each have our own mental images of the characters we love so; I was afraid the artists representations would not match up with my own personal images. However, I was pleasntly surprised by Hoang Nguyen's character sketches. Especially Jamie, which, as we all know is the sole reason most of us are head over heals in love with this series. Claire isn't quite what I had imagined but, all in all, I think the representations of the characters were accurate.
One thing about Gabaldon's novels is they're very descriptive and detailed, and with each book clocking in at over 800+ pages, it stands to reason that there was a lot cut out of
The Exile. While I think die hard
Outlander fans will read this simply because it's another piece of the
Outlander story, I think they'll find it somewhat lacking. There's no way to get the kind of character and plot development in one slim graphic novel that we saw in
Outlander. It's just not possible for the medium. I think those new to the
Outlander story, might be able to enjoy this condensed, visual representation more than long time
Outlander fans.
Lastly, for those of you that have read
Outlander and
The Exile...was the Kenneth character in
Outlander? It's been so long since I've read
Outlander but I don't recall this character. In
The Exile, he came back through the stones as well. Was this a unique element to
The Exile story or do I just have that bad of a memory?!
I'm glad I gave The Exile I chance. It was my first experience reading a graphic novel and I'm always happy to see my favorite Outlander characters. I'm not sure I'll purchase the book, but I might, eventually, to add to my Outlander collection. If you're on the fence, I'd check to see if your local library has a copy!
For those interested, Scribd has
The Making of The Exile which gives readers an insight on how Diana Gabaldon and the artist, Hoang Nguyen, collaborated on
The Exile.
Here are a few pages from The Exile, enjoy!
Claire has a run in with Jack Black Randall.
Jamie on the run!
Last, but ceratanly not least, is this orginal drawing of the wedding night as posted on Diana's
website. This was deemed a bit too explicit and the final image has a blanket covering Jamie's arse!
Rating: